The Fight for Insight: A Matomo and Google Analytics Face Off

Matomo and Google Analytics are two of the top contenders In the world of web analytics. While Google Analytics is renowned for its vast features, Matomo stands out for its commitment to data privacy and customisation. Although our personal journey led us to embrace Matomo to provide us with business insights, the choice between the two will depend on your business needs, with both platforms offering unique strengths.

  • Introduction

    In the digital age, with businesses striving for ever deeper insights and a clearer understanding of their audiences, web analytics tools are indispensable. These tools provide a gateway into the behaviour, preferences, and patterns of website visitors. Today, we’re setting the stage for a face-off between two giants in the field: Matomo and Google Analytics.

    Meet the Contenders

    Web analytics is a crowded arena, but two names stand out: Matomo and Google Analytics.

    Google Analytics

    Originating from the tech giant, Google, this web analytics service has been an industry staple since its introduction in 2005.

    As a part of Google’s extensive suite of tools, it’s been a preferred choice for many businesses, both small and large. Its integration with other Google services, such as AdWords and Search Console, provides a comprehensive digital analytics solution.

    While renowned for its in-depth reporting and user segmentation, some critics highlight concerns over data privacy and the tool’s potential complexity for beginners.

    Matomo (formerly Piwik):

    Matomo emerged in 2007 as an open-source alternative to the dominant players in the web analytics market.

    With a strong emphasis on user privacy and data ownership, Matomo quickly became a favourite among businesses and organisations valuing these principles. Being open-source means it offers a high level of customisation, allowing businesses to tailor it to their specific needs. Over time, Matomo has evolved, adding a plethora of features, including heatmaps, session recordings, and tag management. Its commitment to keeping user data private and not sharing it with third parties is a significant differentiator in the market.

    Looking for a Matomo Agency?

    Feature Showdown

    Data Privacy and Compliance

    Data protection is of growing importance in today’s digital landscape. 

    Although Google Analytics offers anonymisation tools, it continues to send data to Google servers, which doesn’t align with strict GDPR requirements.

    Matomo, championing privacy by design, ensures data stays on the server where it’s installed. This localised storage of data, combined with built-in GDPR tools, gives businesses peace of mind about compliance.

    User Interface and Ease of Use

    Google Analytics boasts a sophisticated interface filled with rich visuals and data representations. However, its vastness can be overwhelming for novices.

    On the other hand, Matomo presents a more intuitive and streamlined dashboard. While it might lack some of the visual intricacies, its straightforward design aids quicker onboarding and data analysis.

    Customisation and Integration

    Google Analytics, especially its premium version, Google Analytics 360, offers an array of customisation options. Yet, it often requires deeper pockets and extensive know-how.

    Matomo’s open-source nature is its trump card. Developers can tweak it to their heart’s content, ensuring it fits every business nuance. Plus, its marketplace has numerous plugins, broadening its capabilities.

    Data Accuracy and Reporting:

    Accuracy is the cornerstone of insightful analytics.

    Google Analytics, when handling extensive data, resorts to data sampling. This method can sometimes skew results, especially for larger websites.

    Matomo stands out by offering unsampled data, ensuring every data point is considered, leading to more precise insights.

    Real-time Data

    Both platforms offer real-time data tracking, but with subtle differences.

    Google Analytics provides a real-time overview of user activity, showing active users, their sources, and the content they’re accessing.

    Matomo’s real-time map, however, offers a visual representation of user activity worldwide, giving businesses a more geographical insight into their audience.

    Mobile App Tracking

    In the mobile age, app tracking is crucial.

    Google Analytics offers Firebase, a dedicated platform for mobile app analytics.

    Matomo counters with its mobile app analytics feature, allowing businesses to gain insights into app user behaviour, events, and more.

    Our Journey with Matomo

    Our co-owner, Michi, was a staunch supporter of Google Analytics for many years. However, the advent of GDPR led many users to opt out of cookie-based tracking for privacy reasons. Coupled with limited options for customisation and the inability to export raw data, he felt a need for change. Enter Matomo.

    The initial setup was challenging, given the learning curve, but the rewards have been significant. 

    Today, Matomo offers us unparalleled control, more creative space for data analysis, and insights that we couldn’t achieve with other platforms. With full access to our own raw data, we’ve even been able to venture into new territories, such as parsing anonymised data with ChatGPT to extract additional insights.

    Which is Right for Your Business?

    As with all tools, the key lies in understanding your requirements and ensuring that the platform aligns with your goals.  The current trend toward Matomo reflects a growing emphasis on data privacy and control, however the choice between Matomo and Google Analytics hinges on your business needs.

    Further Insights